Why Aluminum Foil Has a Dull Side and a Shiny Side - Reynolds Aluminum Foil Wrap

Consider the mystery solved.
According to Reynold's Kitchen, the difference between the two sides of aluminum foil is just a result of manufacturing.

Heavy Duty Foil Reynolds Brands

Why Aluminum Foil Has a Shiny and a Dull Side

Which Side Of The Aluminum Foil Should You Use?

The Difference Between Aluminum and Tin Foil

Reynolds Wrap® Standard Aluminum Foil, 30 Sq.ft.

How to Use Aluminum Foil the Right Way

Pitmaster's Choice Foil

Tin foil – shiny side up or down? - Blue Sky Questions

One side of aluminum foil is shiner than the other. Here's why and when to use it

Everyday Foil Reynolds Brands

Why Aluminum Foil Has a Dull Side and a Shiny Side - Reynolds Aluminum Foil Wrap